Will Boeing Face Criminal Prosecution Over 737 MAX Crashes? DOJ’s Decision Looms

Abhishek Nayar

24 Jun 2024

The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) is currently grappling with a critical decision: whether to pursue a criminal prosecution of Boeing for allegedly violating a deferred prosecution agreement (DPA) established in 2021. This agreement was originally put in place to shield Boeing from criminal prosecution related to two fatal 737 MAX crashes in 2018 and 2019. As the deadline for the DOJ’s decision approaches, the stakes are high for both Boeing and the families of the crash victims.

Background: The Tragic Crashes

In 2018 and 2019, two Boeing 737 MAX aircraft crashed, resulting in the tragic loss of 346 lives. These crashes, occurring in Indonesia and Ethiopia, were attributed to flaws in the aircraft's design, specifically the Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System (MCAS). Following extensive investigations, Boeing faced intense scrutiny and legal challenges.

The 2021 Deferred Prosecution Agreement

In January 2021, Boeing reached a DPA with the DOJ, agreeing to pay $2.5 billion to resolve a criminal investigation into its conduct surrounding the crashes. This agreement required Boeing to overhaul its compliance practices and shielded the company from prosecution over a fraud conspiracy charge.

Alleged Violations and DOJ’s Investigation

In May 2023, the DOJ announced that Boeing had violated the terms of the DPA. This conclusion was reached after an incident involving a new Alaska Airlines Boeing 737 MAX 9 jet on January 5, 2023, exposed continued safety and quality issues at Boeing. Despite these findings, Boeing has maintained that it complied with the agreement.

Conflicting Reports and DOJ’s Response

Recently, the New York Times reported that the DOJ was expected to allow Boeing to avoid criminal prosecution for violating the DPA. However, Glenn Leon, chief of the DOJ’s fraud section, refuted this claim in an email to lawyers representing the victims' families, stating, "The department has not made a decision on how to proceed or whether to pursue prosecution of Boeing." The Times later revised its story to indicate that the DOJ is still considering its options.

Families of Victims Demand Accountability

Families of the victims have long criticized the DOJ’s handling of Boeing's case, arguing that the initial DPA failed to hold the company fully accountable for the crashes. This week, they urged prosecutors to impose a hefty fine of nearly $25 billion on Boeing and to move forward with a criminal prosecution.

DOJ’s Options and Upcoming Deadline

Federal prosecutors have until July 7 to inform a federal judge in Texas of their decision. Their options include proceeding with a criminal case against Boeing, negotiating a plea deal, or extending the deferred prosecution agreement for another year. Each potential outcome carries significant implications for Boeing’s future and its accountability.

What’s Next for Boeing?

As the DOJ deliberates, the aviation industry and the public at large await a resolution. Will the DOJ pursue a criminal prosecution, or will Boeing once again avoid the full force of legal repercussions? The decision will not only impact Boeing but also set a precedent for corporate accountability in cases of severe negligence and misconduct.


The question of Boeing’s accountability remains unanswered as the DOJ weighs its options. For the families of the crash victims and for Boeing itself, the forthcoming decision will be a crucial turning point. The world watches closely, seeking justice for the lives lost and hoping for a future where corporate responsibility takes precedence over profit.

With Inputs from Reuters

Read next

COMAC's Ascent: Will the Chinese Planemaker Disrupt Airbus and Boeing’s Duopoly?

Abhishek Nayar

22 Jun 2024

In an evolving aviation landscape, the duopoly of Airbus and Boeing, the world's leading aircraft manufacturers, is facing potential disruption. The emergence of the Commercial Aircraft Corporation of China (COMAC) as a formidable player in the passenger jet market signifies a shift that could transform the industry. COMAC’s C919 jet, designed to compete with Airbus' A320 and Boeing's 737 MAX, is garnering attention and optimism about breaking the long-standing duopoly.

The Current Market Landscape

Airbus and Boeing dominate the aircraft supply chain for airlines worldwide. However, both companies are currently navigating significant challenges. Airbus is grappling with production bottlenecks amid record-high orders, while Boeing is embroiled in safety investigations and production issues following a mid-air panel blowout incident in January.

COMAC’s Unique Opportunity

Firoz Tarapore, CEO of Dubai Aerospace Enterprise (DAE), one of the top 10 aircraft leasing companies globally, believes that COMAC has a unique opportunity over the next decade. Tarapore described the C919 as a "perfectly fine aircraft" and noted that COMAC could transform the duopoly into a triopoly due to Airbus' production saturation and Boeing's ongoing troubles.

Expanding Horizons: COMAC's Global Ambitions

Currently, COMAC's planes are predominantly operational within China and with an Indonesian airline. The Chinese planemaker is aggressively pursuing certification from Europe’s aviation regulator for its C919 jet, aiming to attract international customers. However, industry insiders caution that without certifications from the U.S. or European Union and the development of more efficient aircraft, COMAC’s international inroads will be challenging.

Robust Demand and Strategic Inroads

Despite these challenges, Tarapore remains optimistic. He highlights the "extremely robust" demand for aircraft in China and nearby regions, suggesting that COMAC has a "very good chance of making a solid inroad." The post-pandemic surge in global travel has led to a spike in aircraft orders. Supply chain issues and maintenance industry labor shortages have caused delivery delays, creating a window of opportunity for COMAC to capture market interest.

Production Woes of Airbus and Boeing

Airbus has announced that production slots for its popular A320 family are fully booked until the decade's end. Meanwhile, Boeing’s situation is more precarious. The company is dealing with a significant safety crisis, ongoing U.S. regulatory investigations, potential prosecutions, and a decline in production rates for its best-selling 737 MAX.

A Vision for the Future

Tarapore envisions a future where the industry is no longer dominated by Airbus and Boeing alone. He hopes Boeing will undergo structural and cultural reforms to return to producing high-quality aircraft at historic production rates. For DAE, which manages a fleet of 500 aircraft, Boeing's delivery delays have impacted their supply chain, receiving only half the expected aircraft this year.


Looking ahead 30 years, Tarapore is confident that the aviation industry will no longer be a duopoly. COMAC is poised to play a much more significant role, driven by robust demand in the Asian market and the persistent challenges faced by Airbus and Boeing. As COMAC continues to innovate and expand, the aviation industry may witness a significant shift, welcoming a new major player into the fold.

The Takeaway

As COMAC strives to gain international certification and efficiency, the landscape of the aviation industry could see substantial changes. Airlines and lessors around the world are closely watching COMAC’s progress, which could redefine competitive dynamics and offer more choices in the global market. The next decade will be crucial in determining whether COMAC can indeed break the Airbus-Boeing duopoly, ushering in an era of triopoly in the passenger jet market.

With Inputs from Reuters

Read next

Is Boeing About to Reacquire Spirit AeroSystems? A Complex Deal on the Horizon

Abhishek Nayar

24 Jun 2024

The aerospace industry is abuzz with speculation and anticipation as Boeing inches closer to potentially reacquiring its former subsidiary, Spirit AeroSystems. This move, which could significantly reshape the dynamics within the sector, has been closely monitored by analysts, investors, and industry insiders. With the mid-year deadline fast approaching, let's dive into the details of this intricate deal and its potential implications.

A Deal in the Making: The Current Status

Last month, Boeing’s Chief Financial Officer, Brian West, indicated that an acquisition deal with Spirit AeroSystems might be finalized by mid-year. Now, with the deadline looming, reports suggest that the agreement is nearing completion. Both The Air Current and Reuters reported on June 20 that an announcement might be imminent, with Boeing possibly revealing the agreement next week.

The Airbus Factor: A Key Player in the Negotiations

One of the most significant complexities of this deal is Spirit AeroSystems' relationship with both Boeing and Airbus. Spirit supplies critical aerostructures to both aerospace giants, necessitating Airbus's involvement in the acquisition discussions. According to Bloomberg, Airbus is close to securing an agreement to acquire several Spirit units that supply its programs. This potential arrangement highlights the intricate nature of the deal and underscores the necessity of careful negotiation to satisfy all parties involved.

Stock Market Reaction: Investor Optimism

The market has responded positively to the prospect of this acquisition. Spirit AeroSystems' stock price surged by approximately 8% on June 21, reflecting investor confidence in the potential benefits of the deal. Despite the enthusiasm, Boeing has remained tight-lipped, declining to comment on the matter, while neither Spirit nor Airbus has responded to requests for comments.

Challenges and Considerations: Spirit's Troubles

Spirit AeroSystems has faced numerous operational and financial challenges in recent years, grappling with quality problems amid labor shortages and incurring substantial losses on its composite structures work. Boeing, which originally owned Spirit before spinning it off in 2005, revealed in March that it was contemplating reacquiring the supplier to address these persistent issues and stabilize a crucial part of its supply chain.

Boeing's Strategic Move: Fixing Supply Chain Issues

Boeing's consideration of this acquisition comes on the heels of a serious incident in January involving an Alaska Airlines 737 Max 9's door-plug failure. Investigations revealed that Boeing employees had improperly reinstalled a door plug initially removed for Spirit personnel to fix a rivet issue. This incident underscored the critical need for Boeing to streamline and secure its supply chain, making the potential reacquisition of Spirit a strategic move.

Airbus's Potential Acquisitions: A Global Impact

For Airbus, the potential acquisition of Spirit units is significant. Bloomberg reported that Airbus is nearing a deal to acquire operations in Kinston, North Carolina; Saint-Nazaire, France; Belfast, Northern Ireland; and Prestwick, Scotland. These facilities are integral to Airbus's production, with Kinston producing A350 center-fuselage sections and Belfast manufacturing A220 wings. Such acquisitions would allow Airbus to maintain control over critical components of its supply chain, mitigating any disruptions from Boeing’s potential reacquisition of Spirit.

The Path Forward: Divestitures and Defense Contracts

A Boeing acquisition of Spirit AeroSystems is far from straightforward. Analysts suggest that Spirit would likely need to divest its Airbus-related work as a prerequisite. Additionally, Spirit's involvement in classified defense programs could pose competitive conflicts if integrated into Boeing’s operations, necessitating further divestitures or restructuring.

Conclusion: A Deal to Watch

As the deadline approaches, the aerospace industry watches closely. The potential reacquisition of Spirit AeroSystems by Boeing is a complex and multi-faceted deal with significant implications for both Boeing and Airbus. While the final outcome remains uncertain, the developments in the coming weeks will undoubtedly shape the future of the aerospace supply chain. Stay tuned as this high-stakes negotiation unfolds.

With Inputs from Flight Global

Read next

American Airlines Flight Attendants Edge Closer to Strike

Abhishek Nayar

22 Jun 2024

The Association of Professional Flight Attendants (APFA), representing approximately 28,000 flight attendants at American Airlines, has reported that the latest round of negotiations with the airline has ended without a resolution. The union revealed on Thursday that no favorable agreement was presented by the carrier, moving the attendants one step closer to a potential strike.

The Path to a Strike: A Complex Journey

Despite the mounting tensions, the flight attendants cannot initiate a strike without the approval of the National Mediation Board (NMB). The NMB must first determine that both parties are at an impasse and that further negotiations would be futile. This intricate and prolonged process significantly complicates the possibility of a strike for airline workers.

In a statement emailed to Reuters, American Airlines expressed its commitment to ongoing negotiations, emphasizing the potential for a mutually beneficial agreement. "This agreement is within reach and we look forward to additional dates being scheduled," an airline spokesperson stated.

Negotiations: A Timeline of Turmoil

The current series of negotiations commenced in January 2020 but faced a hiatus during the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic, resuming in June 2021. Earlier this month, American Airlines proposed an immediate 17% wage increase for its flight attendants, a proposition that the APFA unanimously rejected.

Union’s Stance and Next Steps

The APFA has been vocal about its dissatisfaction with the airline's offers, underscoring the need for a contract that better reflects the flight attendants' contributions and demands. The union's call for a strike authorization vote signals its readiness to escalate actions if necessary.

Potential Implications for Travelers

As the negotiations continue, passengers may wonder about the potential impact on their travel plans. While the immediate threat of a strike remains controlled by the NMB’s processes, prolonged uncertainty and tension could affect service quality and operational efficiency.


With the APFA and American Airlines locked in a stalemate, the future remains uncertain for the carrier's flight attendants. Both sides acknowledge the need for a resolution, yet the road to an agreement is fraught with challenges. As the skies over American Airlines grow stormier, passengers and employees alike await the next developments in this high-stakes negotiation.

With Inputs from Reuters

Read next

Why Are India and China Still Not Resuming Direct Flights?

Abhishek Nayar

22 Jun 2024

Relations between India and China have been fraught with tension since a deadly military confrontation on their disputed Himalayan border in June 2020, which resulted in the deaths of 20 Indian soldiers and at least four Chinese soldiers. The clash has had a lasting impact, with thousands of troops remaining mobilized on each side of the border. This ongoing military standoff has significantly strained diplomatic ties and influenced various facets of bilateral relations, including economic exchanges and transportation links.

Direct Flights: A Casualty of Political Tensions

The cessation of direct passenger flights between India and China, which began four years ago, is one of the prominent manifestations of these strained relations. Despite multiple requests from China to restart these flights, India has been reluctant to comply. The primary reason, according to a senior Indian official, is the lack of "peace and tranquility on the border," which is seen as a prerequisite for improving other aspects of the relationship.

The Economic Stakes: More Than Just Flights

Direct flights between the two nations would undoubtedly benefit both economies. However, the stakes appear higher for China. The recovery of overseas travel in China post-COVID-19 has been sluggish, while India's aviation sector is experiencing significant growth. The absence of direct flights has extended travel times and increased costs for passengers, making travel between the two countries more cumbersome. Travelers now have to transit through third-party hubs such as Dubai, Singapore, or Hong Kong, thereby benefiting airlines like Emirates, Singapore Airlines, and Cathay Pacific instead of direct carriers from India and China.

The Business Perspective: Airlines and Companies in Limbo

Both Indian and Chinese airlines are eager to resume direct flights. Pieter Elbers, CEO of IndiGo, India’s largest airline, mentioned ongoing discussions with Indian authorities. However, the resolution appears contingent on broader geopolitical developments. On the Chinese side, airlines are also in talks with their government, highlighting the importance of resuming these routes.

Chinese businesses, particularly in the technology sector, have faced increased scrutiny in India since the 2020 clash. India's regulatory measures against Chinese companies have included bans on popular apps and tightened investment regulations. Companies like Xiaomi have expressed concerns, citing compliance and visa challenges that deter component suppliers from setting up operations in India. These issues further complicate the prospects for normalizing direct flights.

Historical Context: The Peak and Plunge of Direct Flights

In December 2019, direct flights between India and China reached their peak with 539 scheduled flights. Chinese carriers operated the majority, with 371 flights, compared to 168 by Indian airlines. The pandemic led to a halt in these operations in early 2020. Although India lifted COVID-19 restrictions on international air routes a year later and China followed in early 2023, direct flights have yet to resume.

The Future of India-China Air Travel: A Waiting Game

The reinstatement of direct flights remains a significant issue for China, as echoed by their Foreign Ministry's call for cooperation from India. For Indian airlines, the potential market is substantial, yet political factors remain a barrier. Campbell Wilson, CEO of Air India, emphasized that while the market potential is vast, the current situation is influenced by factors beyond the airlines' control.

Conclusion: Navigating a Complex Terrain

The resumption of direct flights between India and China is emblematic of the broader challenges in their bilateral relations. While there are clear economic incentives for both nations, the prevailing border tensions and political dynamics play a crucial role in determining the future of these air routes. For now, travelers and businesses must navigate the extended travel times and indirect routes as the two nations work through their geopolitical differences.

With Inputs from Reuters

Read next

SIA Group Soars Beyond Pre-Pandemic Heights

Abhishek Nayar

22 Jun 2024

Fresh off its highest-ever revenue and profit figures in a financial year, the Singapore Airlines Group (SIA Group) has continued its remarkable momentum with impressive performance numbers in May. The group, which includes Singapore Airlines and its low-cost subsidiary Scoot, has consistently exceeded pre-pandemic traffic levels in recent months, cementing its position as a leader in the aviation industry.

Passenger Growth Surges Ahead

In May, the SIA Group carried an impressive 3.23 million passengers, marking a 14.3% increase from the 2.83 million passengers transported in May 2023. This figure also represents a 6% rise from the 3.05 million passengers carried in May 2019, demonstrating the group's robust recovery and growth trajectory post-COVID-19.

Load Factor Insights

Despite a slight year-on-year (YoY) drop in passenger load factor from 88.0% in May 2023 to 86.1% in May 2024, the group's load factor remains significantly higher than the 80.5% recorded in 2019. The YoY decline is attributed to a 12.6% increase in capacity, as measured by available seat kilometers (ASK), and a 10.2% rise in revenue passenger kilometers (RPK). This strategic capacity expansion has been managed carefully, allowing the group to anticipate further load factor improvements in the coming months.

Singapore Airlines: Leading the Charge

Singapore Airlines has shown exceptional performance, with passenger numbers rising by 19.2% in May 2024 compared to the previous year. The full-service carrier transported 2.17 million passengers at a load factor of 85.6%, up from 1.82 million in May 2023, though slightly down from last year's 87.2%. The airline's ability to add capacity on popular routes while maintaining high load factors highlights its strategic acumen in load management and market responsiveness.

Scoot: Consistent Growth and Expansion

Scoot, the group's low-cost carrier, continues to outpace its pre-pandemic performance. In May 2024, Scoot carried 1.06 million passengers, a 5.4% increase from the 1 million passengers transported in May 2023. Despite a 2.6 percentage point dip in load factor to 88.1%, Scoot's capacity expansion by 4.2% and a 1.2% increase in RPK underline its steady growth.

Geographical Load Factors and New Routes

Scoot's load factors varied across its three geographical segments, with the Rest of the World (including Australia) leading at 91.2%, followed by West Asia at 89.7% and East Asia at 86.8%. The introduction of passenger flights to Koh Samui, Thailand, utilizing its new Embraer E190-E2 aircraft, marks a significant milestone in Scoot's fleet expansion and route diversification.

Expanding Network and Reach

By the end of May, the SIA Group's passenger network encompassed 123 destinations across 36 countries and territories. Singapore Airlines served 77 destinations, while Scoot operated in 68, showcasing the group's extensive reach and connectivity. Additionally, the cargo network spanned 127 destinations in 37 countries and territories, further solidifying the group's global presence.

Conclusion: A Bright Horizon

The Singapore Airlines Group's exceptional performance in May 2024 is a testament to its strategic planning, capacity management, and market responsiveness. As the group continues to expand its network and optimize load factors, it is poised for continued growth and success, leaving the challenges of the COVID-19 era firmly in the past. With record-breaking revenues and a robust recovery trajectory, the SIA Group is not just soaring back to pre-pandemic heights but is well on its way to reaching new altitudes in the aviation industry.