Is the Future of Turkish Airlines' A320 Fleet in Jeopardy Due to Engine Issues?
Abhishek Nayar
09 Jul 2024

Earlier this week, Turkish Airlines announced it had reached a compensation agreement with International Aero Engines (IAE). This settlement aims to address the operational disruptions and financial losses caused by the persistent issues with Pratt & Whitney's PW1100G-JM engines, used on the airline's A320 family aircraft.
The Engine Dilemma
For over a year, problems with Pratt & Whitney's PW1100G-JM engines have plagued operators worldwide, including Turkish Airlines. These issues have forced airlines to ground numerous Airbus A320neo and A321neo aircraft, causing significant operational disruptions. Turkish Airlines, which operates 58 aircraft powered by the affected engine type, has seen around 20 of these planes grounded.
Global Impact and Compensation Efforts
The global scale of disruption due to the engine issues has prompted other airlines, such as Spirit Airlines and Air Astana, to secure compensation agreements with IAE to cover their operational costs. The A320neo is the backbone of short and medium-haul operations for many airlines globally, and the impact extends to over 50 airlines and leasing operators worldwide.
The affected engines, manufactured between 2015 and 2021, number over 3,000, requiring inspection and potential repairs. With the rise in passenger demand post-pandemic, airlines are in dire need of operational capacity, leading them to take creative measures to mitigate the impact of grounded A320s.
Strategies to Cope with Grounded Aircraft
To handle the operational challenges, airlines are adopting various strategies. Some carriers are modifying their schedules to minimize disruptions, while others are leasing additional aircraft or extending the service life of their older planes. For instance, German carrier Lufthansa has continued operating its older A320-200s to ensure sufficient capacity, anticipating that up to 20 of its newer A320neo aircraft could be out of service at any given time.
Long-Term Implications
It is estimated that until 2026, over 300 A320 aircraft will be affected annually as engine manufacturers conduct inspections to ensure safety. The main issue lies in the potential for microscopic cracks to form on the engine's high-pressure turbine disks due to a rare problem with the powdered metal used in their construction. While Pratt & Whitney assures that this is not an immediate threat, the engines must undergo inspection ahead of the planned maintenance schedule.
The Path Forward for Turkish Airlines
Turkish Airlines' compensation agreement with IAE is a significant step in addressing the immediate operational disruptions. However, the long-term implications for the airline and the global aviation industry remain uncertain. With ongoing inspections and potential repairs, airlines must continue to adapt their operations to ensure they can meet rising passenger demands while maintaining safety and efficiency.
Conclusion
The issues with Pratt & Whitney's PW1100G-JM engines have caused widespread disruptions across the aviation industry, impacting airlines like Turkish Airlines significantly. While compensation agreements provide some relief, the industry faces ongoing challenges as it navigates the complexities of maintaining and operating a large fleet of affected aircraft. As the situation evolves, airlines will need to remain flexible and innovative to ensure their operations continue smoothly and safely.
Read next
Russia's aviation sector is facing significant challenges, with S7 Airlines at the center of a storm involving grounded aircraft, Western sanctions, and controversial government policies. Dmitry Yadrov, head of Russia’s civil aviation regulator (Rosaviatsiya), has confirmed that S7 Airlines is struggling to keep its fleet of Airbus A320neo and A321neo aircraft operational due to difficulties maintaining their Pratt & Whitney PW1000G engines. Additionally, S7 Airlines opposes a Kremlin plan to fund airport reconstruction through airline revenues, a move that could lead to higher ticket prices for passengers.
Engine Troubles Ground S7’s Fleet
Western Sanctions Take a Toll
S7 Airlines' ability to maintain its fleet has been severely hampered by Western sanctions, which have disrupted the supply of essential parts for the Pratt & Whitney PW1000G engines powering their Airbus A320neo and A321neo aircraft. Yadrov disclosed to the Russian news agency TASS on July 1 that these maintenance issues could impact overall passenger numbers in Russia, with forecasts predicting a 7% decline to 98.1 million passengers this year.
A Growing Fleet of Grounded Aircraft
According to data from the ch-aviation fleets module, S7 Airlines operates thirty-one A320-200Ns, of which fifteen are currently grounded, an increase from five nine months ago. All four A321-200Ns and four A321-200NXs are also grounded. The inability to perform necessary repairs on these aircraft has forced S7 to trim its winter schedule by 10-15% compared to the previous year.
Opposition to Kremlin’s Airport Reconstruction Plan
Financial Burden on Airlines
In a separate development, S7 Airlines has voiced its opposition to a Kremlin initiative to rebuild airport runways and terminals using funds sourced from airline revenues. This plan involves creating the Air Transport Infrastructure Fund, which will be financed by increased air navigation fees for airlines. S7 Airlines and Aeroflot have both warned that this additional financial burden will ultimately be passed on to passengers through higher ticket prices.
Rising Costs and Potential Impacts
S7 Airlines highlighted that airport costs have already risen significantly in recent years, particularly at airports where new terminals have been constructed. An S7 spokesperson told RBK that since November 2022, air navigation fees have increased by 76%, and further increases could lead to a general rise in air ticket prices across the market. Aeroflot echoed these concerns, emphasizing that passengers would bear the cost of the proposed fund.
Legal Battles on the Horizon
S7 Airlines vs. Tsifra Broker
Amid these operational challenges and policy disputes, S7 Airlines is also embroiled in a legal battle. The Moscow Arbitration Court is set to hear a claim from S7 Airlines against Tsifra Broker, a Moscow-based investment firm, for RUB1 billion (USD11.16 million) on July 10. The case pertains to alleged losses stemming from Tsifra Broker's improper performance of obligations related to the acquisition of shares and depositary receipts in the technology company Yandex NV.
Conclusion
As S7 Airlines navigates the dual challenges of grounded aircraft and contentious government policies, the impact on Russia's aviation sector remains uncertain. With passenger numbers projected to fall and legal battles looming, the coming months will be critical in determining the future trajectory of both S7 Airlines and the broader industry. Passengers, meanwhile, brace for potential increases in ticket prices as airlines grapple with these multifaceted issues.
With Inputs from ch-aviation
Read next
Biman Bangladesh Airlines, the national flag carrier of Bangladesh, is embarking on an ambitious journey to nearly double its fleet size over the next 11 years. The newly appointed Managing Director and CEO, Mohammad Jahidul Islam Bhuiyan, who took the helm in May 2024, has laid out an extensive plan that aims to expand the airline's fleet from the current 21 aircraft to 47 by 2035. This strategic move marks a significant investment in new aircraft, positioning Biman for substantial growth and enhanced global presence.
Fleet Expansion Plan
Current Fleet and Future Needs
As of now, Biman Bangladesh Airlines operates a fleet of 21 aircraft. However, six of these aircraft are slated to be phased out by 2035 due to age and operational efficiency considerations. To achieve the target of 47 aircraft, Bhuiyan's plan includes the acquisition of an additional 32 aircraft. This expansion is essential for the airline's route development and overall growth strategy.
Recent Acquisitions
In a recent development, Biman's board has approved the acquisition of four Airbus A350-900s, securing funding through the UK's Export Finance scheme. This acquisition is a significant step towards modernizing the fleet and enhancing passenger experience with state-of-the-art aircraft.
Strategic Partnerships: Airbus and Boeing
Airbus Advancements
Discussions with Airbus have progressed significantly, highlighting a strong potential partnership for future acquisitions. The A350-900s, known for their fuel efficiency and long-range capabilities, are set to play a pivotal role in Biman's fleet enhancement strategy. These aircraft will not only improve operational efficiency but also offer passengers a more comfortable and modern flying experience.
Boeing's Proposal
While Airbus has made notable strides, Boeing is also in the running to supply aircraft to Biman. Bhuiyan confirmed that Boeing has presented its proposal, which the airline is currently reviewing. The inclusion of Boeing aircraft would diversify the fleet and ensure a balanced approach to expansion, leveraging the strengths of both leading manufacturers.
Financial and Operational Considerations
Investment Requirements
The ambitious expansion plan requires substantial financial investment. Securing funding, as demonstrated by the UK's Export Finance scheme for the A350-900s, will be a crucial component of the strategy. Biman will need to explore various financing options, including government support, international loans, and partnerships with financial institutions.
Operational Readiness
Expanding the fleet is not just about acquiring new aircraft; it also involves preparing the airline's operational infrastructure to support the larger fleet. This includes enhancing maintenance facilities, training additional pilots and crew, and upgrading airport operations to handle increased traffic.
Conclusion
Biman Bangladesh Airlines, under the visionary leadership of Mohammad Jahidul Islam Bhuiyan, is poised for a transformative decade. By 2035, the airline aims to nearly double its fleet size, positioning itself as a major player in the global aviation industry. With strategic partnerships with Airbus and Boeing, and a clear focus on financial and operational readiness, Biman is set to soar to new heights. The journey ahead is challenging but promising, heralding a new era of growth and success for Bangladesh's national flag carrier.
With Inputs from ch-aviation
Read next
European airline consolidation has been a hot topic in the aviation industry, especially as major players like Lufthansa, IAG, and Air France-KLM seek to expand their footprints through strategic acquisitions. However, increasing scrutiny from European regulators poses significant challenges. The recent approval of Lufthansa’s acquisition of a 41% stake in ITA Airways, following a year-long negotiation with the European Commission, underscores the complexities involved. This article delves into the implications of these regulatory hurdles and what they mean for the future of airline mergers and acquisitions in Europe.
Lufthansa's Acquisition of ITA Airways: A Case Study
Lufthansa’s purchase of ITA Airways highlights both the opportunities and obstacles in the current regulatory landscape. Despite the acquisition expanding Lufthansa’s presence in the lucrative southern European market, it came with significant concessions. To gain approval, Lufthansa had to cede certain routes and slots to competitors, reflecting the European Commission’s cautious stance on consolidation.
The Regulatory Gauntlet
The European Commission’s stringent scrutiny of airline mergers aims to prevent market monopolies that could harm consumer choice and drive-up prices. This heightened vigilance can deter airlines from pursuing deals, fearing prolonged legal battles, high costs, and the loss of valuable assets. British Airways-owner IAG’s protracted efforts to acquire Spanish carrier Air Europa since 2019 exemplify these challenges. With an EU deadline for concessions approaching, the future of this deal remains uncertain.
The Role of Government Stakes and Strategic Assets
National carriers often hold strategic importance for governments, complicating potential mergers. The political and economic significance of these airlines means governments are reluctant to relinquish control completely. Portugal’s TAP is a prime example, with its CEO advocating for a partial sale involving non-aviation investors to alleviate regulatory concerns.
Market Dynamics: The Rise of Low-Cost Carriers
While major airline groups face regulatory headwinds, low-cost carriers like Ryanair continue to expand rapidly. Ryanair’s dominance in Italy, where it holds over 40% market share, was notably absent from the European Commission’s assessment during Lufthansa’s ITA acquisition. This oversight raises questions about the comprehensive nature of regulatory evaluations and whether low-cost carriers’ market influence is being adequately considered.
Industry Perspectives
Airline executives argue that consolidation is necessary to mitigate soaring operating costs and recover from the COVID-19 pandemic’s severe impact. However, they also express frustration over the European Commission’s demands. EasyJet CEO Johan Lundgren highlights the paradox that without consolidation, airlines may continue relying on government bailouts, which could be more detrimental in the long run.
The Future of Airline Consolidation in Europe
The path forward for airline mergers in Europe appears fraught with regulatory challenges. While consolidation can bring operational efficiencies and stabilize the industry, the European Commission’s rigorous oversight aims to preserve competitive markets. The balance between these two objectives will shape the landscape of European aviation in the coming years.
Conclusion
As the debate over airline consolidation continues, the European aviation industry must navigate a complex regulatory environment. The outcomes of high-profile mergers, such as Lufthansa’s stake in ITA Airways and IAG’s bid for Air Europa, will serve as benchmarks for future deals. Striking a balance between fostering competition and enabling industry growth remains the key challenge for regulators and airlines alike.
With Inputs from Reuters
Read next
India's air cargo sector is on the brink of a significant transformation. With the government actively working to develop logistics hubs and improve operational efficiencies, the future looks promising for this critical industry. Senior government officials and industry leaders are optimistic about the sector's growth, driven by initiatives aimed at enhancing processes, ensuring faster turnaround times, and better utilization of existing facilities.
Government's Vision for Air Cargo
Piyush Srivastava's Insight
Piyush Srivastava, Senior Economic Advisor at the Ministry of Civil Aviation, recently highlighted the bright future of India's air cargo sector. Speaking at a conference organized by the Air Cargo Forum India (ACFI) in the national capital, he emphasized the importance of improving the ease of doing business and reducing turnaround times. With only 18 freighters currently operating in the country, there is substantial room for growth, and Srivastava expects the number of freighters to rise significantly in the coming years.
Focus on Logistics Hubs
The government's strategy includes developing logistics hubs to streamline operations and improve efficiency. These hubs are expected to play a pivotal role in the sector's expansion, enabling quicker and more efficient handling of cargo.
Current State and Challenges
Recovery Post-Pandemic
While passenger traffic has rebounded to pre-pandemic levels, the air cargo sector is still on its path to recovery. In the fiscal year 2023-24, India handled a little over 3.36 million tonnes of air cargo, indicating a need for further growth to match pre-Covid levels.
Surendra Kumar Ahirwar's Perspective
Surendra Kumar Ahirwar, Joint Secretary at the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT), emphasized the ongoing developments in logistics, including the skilling of personnel. However, he pointed out that there is sub-optimal utilization of existing air cargo facilities. To address this, Ahirwar stressed the importance of developing hubs as part of the broader logistics infrastructure.
Industry Insights and Future Prospects
Revenue Contribution
According to ACFI President Yashpal Sharma, the air cargo sector contributes nearly 10% of domestic carriers' revenues. This highlights the sector's significant role in the overall aviation industry.
Market Growth Projections
Market research reports predict robust growth for India's air freight market, estimating it to reach USD 16.37 billion by 2027. This optimistic outlook is driven by plans to establish air transport shipment hubs at major airports, which are expected to further propel the industry's growth.
Conclusion
The concerted efforts by the government and industry stakeholders to improve processes, develop logistics hubs, and enhance operational efficiencies are set to unlock the immense potential of India's air cargo sector. As the country moves towards becoming a global logistics hub, the sector's growth will not only boost the aviation industry but also contribute significantly to the economy. With the right strategies in place, the sky is truly the limit for India's air cargo sector.
Read next
In the fiscal year 2023-24, Kempegowda International Airport Bengaluru (KIAB/BLR Airport) has once again solidified its position as India's top airport for exporting perishables. This marks the fourth consecutive year BLR Airport has achieved this milestone, reflecting its pivotal role in enhancing India's perishable export capabilities.
Record-Breaking Growth in Perishable Cargo
During FY 2023-24, BLR Airport recorded an impressive total perishable cargo tonnage of 63,188 metric tons (MT), marking an 18% growth compared to the previous fiscal year. This achievement underscores BLR Airport's significant contribution to India's perishable exports, handling 28% of the nation's total perishable cargo.
Dominance in Poultry Product Exports
BLR Airport secured the top position for poultry product exports in FY 2023-24, shipping an astounding 47,041 metric tons. Additionally, the airport exported 2,050 metric tons of flowers, with poultry, fresh vegetables, fresh fruits, and flowers emerging as the leading perishable cargo categories.
Leadership in South India's Perishable Exports
BLR Airport processed 44% of South India’s total perishable cargo, reinforcing its status as the premier gateway to South and Central India. Satyaki Raghunath, Chief Operating Officer at Bangalore International Airport Limited, expressed pride in this consistent growth, stating, "This milestone reflects our commitment to excellence in an unbroken cold chain and the trust placed in us by our partners and customers."
Strategic Connectivity Enhancing Export Capacity
As a crucial gateway, BLR Airport significantly enhances connectivity, linking Indian producers with key international markets. The airport's extensive network facilitates seamless transportation of perishable goods to over 100 global destinations, including Oman, Singapore, Qatar, UAE, Maldives, UK, and Kuwait. This connectivity ensures that fresh produce reaches international buyers swiftly and efficiently, boosting the export capacity of southern India.
State-of-the-Art Infrastructure
BLR Airport is home to WFS BLR Coolport, India’s first integrated on-airport Perishable Handling Centre with a terminal capacity of 40,000 metric tons. This facility, designed exclusively for perishable cold chain cargo, features on-site regulatory services, including plant and animal quarantine inspections, a drug controller lab, and Indian Customs.
Commitment to Excellence and Growth
By continuously improving its infrastructure and services, BLR Airport is committed to supporting the growing demand for perishable goods. The airport's strategic initiatives underscore its role as a crucial hub for agricultural and horticultural exports in India, ensuring it remains at the forefront of the industry, driving economic growth and fostering international trade relationships.
Conclusion
BLR Airport's consistent leadership in perishable exports highlights its critical role in global trade and its commitment to excellence. As the airport continues to enhance its infrastructure and connectivity, it solidifies its position as a key player in the international export landscape, driving economic growth and supporting India's agricultural and horticultural sectors.
By addressing the growing demand for perishable goods and maintaining an unbroken cold chain, BLR Airport ensures that India’s fresh produce reaches international markets efficiently and in prime condition.
Comment