Are Airline Delivery Delays Here to Stay? Frustration Grows as Airbus and Boeing Struggle to Keep Up
Abhishek Nayar
19 Oct 2024
The global airline industry is experiencing a growing sense of frustration due to delivery delays from two of the world's largest planemakers, Airbus and Boeing. The delays, described as "massively frustrating," are causing significant capacity constraints for airlines across Europe. International Air Transport Association (IATA) Director General, Willie Walsh, shared the industry's concerns during a discussion with an Irish think-tank, emphasizing that while the situation has stabilized, it shows no signs of immediate improvement.
A Worrying Outlook for Airlines
Airlines, particularly those in Europe, are feeling the pinch of these delays. Ryanair, Europe's largest low-cost carrier, recently announced that it would have to adjust its passenger traffic estimates for the coming year due to the prolonged wait for new aircraft. This unexpected revision reflects the broader challenges faced by airlines, as their growth plans are severely impacted by the delayed deliveries.
"It’s going to be a problem for a number of years to come," Walsh said, highlighting the long-term nature of the issue. Though the delivery situation appears to have plateaued, it is far from improving. As airlines plan for the future, this unpredictability makes it difficult to manage capacity and meet demand.
Supply Chain Issues and Strikes Worsen the Crisis
The primary cause of these delays can be traced back to ongoing supply chain disruptions, a lingering issue that both Airbus and Boeing are struggling to resolve. For Boeing, the situation is further compounded by an ongoing strike, which has raised alarms about even longer delays at the U.S. manufacturer. The strike, in conjunction with a broader crisis surrounding Boeing’s safety reputation in recent years, paints a bleak picture for the company’s delivery capabilities.
Airbus, Boeing's main rival, has also been grappling with its own supply chain hurdles, resulting in a delivery backlog that has left airlines scrambling to fill gaps in their fleets. With demand for air travel steadily rising post-pandemic, these delays are stifling the growth ambitions of many airlines.
Capacity Crunch Hits European Airlines Hard
The impact of these delivery delays is perhaps most acutely felt by European airlines. At a recent conference in Brussels, several leading carriers voiced their concerns about the resulting capacity constraints. Ryanair, British Airways, and Lufthansa have all been forced to reconsider their future fleet strategies, with the former reducing its passenger traffic projections for the upcoming year.
Adding to the frustration is the competitive advantage enjoyed by Chinese airlines, who, unlike their European counterparts, are allowed to fly over Russian airspace. Since Russia's invasion of Ukraine, European airlines have been banned from accessing Russian airspace, forcing them to take longer, more expensive routes to destinations in Asia. This puts them at a significant disadvantage compared to Chinese airlines, who can offer shorter and more cost-efficient flights on Europe-Asia routes.
Call for a Level Playing Field in Global Aviation
At the heart of this issue is the call for a level playing field in the global aviation market. European carriers are urging Brussels to take action and address what they see as an unfair advantage for Chinese airlines. The European Union, however, appears to have limited options to retaliate against Chinese carriers flying through Russian airspace.
Walsh, who previously led IAG (the parent company of British Airways), suggested that there are no immediate solutions. "Our view, from IATA’s point of view, is Russian airspace should be open to everybody. This is a political issue, not a security or safety issue," he explained.
Though European airlines are pushing for change, Walsh was candid in his assessment, saying he does not see any viable instrument to address the imbalance. For now, airlines must continue to navigate both the delivery delays from planemakers and the geopolitical challenges that affect their flight routes.
What Lies Ahead for the Airline Industry?
Looking ahead, the airline industry must brace for continued uncertainty. The ongoing delivery delays from Airbus and Boeing are likely to persist for several years, impacting growth strategies and operational efficiency. For airlines operating in a highly competitive environment, the inability to expand their fleets will make it difficult to meet the rising demand for air travel.
As supply chain issues and strikes contribute to the backlog, the road to recovery looks long and winding. Meanwhile, the geopolitical tensions over Russian airspace will continue to put European airlines at a disadvantage against their Chinese competitors.
For now, the industry's frustration is palpable. Whether Airbus and Boeing can turn the tide and meet their delivery targets remains to be seen, but the global airline industry is clearly feeling the strain of this ongoing crisis.
With Inputs from Reuters
Read next
The Great Airline Merger: Vistara and Air India Join Forces—What’s Next for Passengers?
Abhishek Nayar
18 Oct 2024
The highly anticipated merger of Vistara and Air India, set for November 11, 2024, marks a significant consolidation of India's aviation industry under the Tata Group. With both airlines boasting unique strengths, the merger is expected to bring about a more seamless and enhanced flying experience. However, for frequent flyers, there are a lot of questions about what this means in terms of services, branding, and overall passenger experience.
What the Merger Means for Passengers
The combined entity will bring the best practices from both Vistara and Air India. While Air India is known for its extensive global network and legacy, Vistara—a joint venture between Tata Group and Singapore Airlines—has built a reputation for premium services, in-flight comfort, and punctuality.
One of the key concerns that many passengers have is whether Vistara’s high service standards will be upheld post-merger, given that Air India has been undergoing a transformation phase but still faces some operational challenges. Bhaskar Bhat, the Chairman of Vistara, emphasized that the focus will remain on empowering frontline staff to deliver consistent and exceptional services. This approach is aimed at ensuring that passengers continue to receive a high level of care, even as the two airlines combine their operations.
A Unified Brand and Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs)
One of the key change’s passengers will notice is the shift towards a single brand identity. As part of the merger, Air India and Vistara will align their Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs). This integration means that everything from in-flight services to booking systems will become standardized across the new, unified airline.
However, Vistara’s livery—its distinctive aircraft design—will stay for some time even after the merger, according to Bhaskar Bhat. The logistics of repainting planes will take time, and grounding aircraft for this task could lead to revenue losses, which is something the new entity is keen to avoid during this crucial transition.
Bhat also pointed out that despite the merger, Vistara’s premiumization efforts will continue. This means that the enhanced experiences that have set Vistara apart—like better in-flight meals, superior cabin comfort, and attentive service—will be incorporated into the combined airline.
Challenges in the Transition
The process of merging two airlines of this scale isn’t without its challenges. Bhat mentioned logistical hurdles, such as aircraft availability and operational adjustments, but reassured that the Vistara experience will remain intact for some time.
One practical challenge is the rebranding of the Vistara fleet, which requires repainting planes. This is a slow process, not only due to the logistics but also the operational impact of removing planes from service. As the airlines integrate, Vistara’s flight numbers will change to align with Air India’s numbering system. For example, flights currently designated under Vistara's "UK" code will transition to Air India’s "AI" flight numbers, yet bookings will remain accessible through Air India’s platforms.
Will Vistara’s Service Excellence Continue?
One of the major concerns for passengers is whether the superior service quality of Vistara will survive the merger. Many travelers choose Vistara for its superior in-flight experience, and there are fears that Air India’s ongoing challenges might affect the standard.
Addressing these concerns, both Air India and Vistara’s leadership teams have reassured passengers that the Vistara experience will not only be preserved but also serve as a benchmark for improving Air India’s offerings. This will be crucial as the combined entity works to differentiate itself in the market by elevating the overall passenger experience.
The Road Ahead for the Indian Aviation Giant
The merger is part of the Tata Group’s broader strategy to consolidate and strengthen its airline businesses. The group has been working on this integration for over a year, ensuring that the transition is smooth for both staff and passengers. By creating a single SOP and organizational structure, Tata hopes to streamline operations and take advantage of the combined resources of the two airlines.
For now, Vistara’s brand will “fly into the sunset” slowly—retaining its identity in certain areas as the practicalities of the merger unfold. Passengers can look forward to the best of both worlds: Air India’s global reach coupled with Vistara’s premium services.
Conclusion: A New Era in Indian Aviation
As November 11, 2024, approaches, the aviation world will watch closely to see how this merger reshapes India’s airline landscape. For passengers, this integration could mean improved connectivity, enhanced services, and a truly world-class flying experience.
While challenges remain, the merger represents a bold step forward for Tata Group’s aviation ambitions. With both airlines bringing their strengths to the table, the unified entity is poised to offer something unique in the Indian aviation sector—blending heritage with modernity, and reach with luxury.
Read next
Is Emirates Preparing for a Cargo Revolution with More Boeing 777F Freighters?
Abhishek Nayar
18 Oct 2024
As global cargo trade surges, Emirates, one of the world’s largest cargo carriers, is strategically expanding its fleet of Boeing 777F freighters. This move comes amidst a growing demand for freighter planes, delays in passenger jet production, and the airline's ambitious plans to significantly boost its cargo capacity in the coming decade. Let’s dive into what this means for Emirates and the broader aviation industry.
An Order Amid Tensions: Boeing 777F Freighters in Demand
While Boeing faces scrutiny for delays in its 777X jetliner series, Emirates is focused on its growing cargo needs. Industry sources have confirmed that Emirates has placed fresh orders for the current-generation Boeing 777F freighters. Although Boeing had announced orders for 11 of these freighters from unidentified buyers in September, it is now clear that part of this order belongs to Emirates.
The timing of this new order comes amid ongoing frustrations expressed by Emirates President Tim Clark regarding Boeing’s handling of the 777X delays. The 777X, which was initially slated for an earlier debut, has now been postponed until 2026, contributing to a six-year delay. Despite these setbacks, Emirates remains the largest operator of the Boeing 777 family and the largest customer awaiting the 777X.
Emirates' Expanding Freighter Fleet: What's Next?
Emirates currently operates a fleet of around 12 Boeing 777F cargo jets and has four more already on order. According to data from Cirium Ascend and Boeing, the airline is also leasing four Boeing 747 freighters to meet the growing demand for air cargo transport.
In a move to triple its cargo capacity by 2030, Emirates has also entered into discussions for the freighter versions of the Airbus A350 and Boeing's future 777X freighter model. The airline is expected to announce a significant investment in additional freighters in the coming weeks, signaling an aggressive push toward dominating the global air freight market.
The Global Air Freight Landscape: Why Freighters Are Crucial
The airline industry’s reliance on dedicated freighter planes has grown significantly, especially as delays in passenger jet production continue to hamper overall capacity. A large portion of air freight typically travels in the cargo holds of passenger aircraft, but as airlines face production challenges with both Boeing and Airbus, the need for specialized freighter planes has become more pronounced.
According to Cirium Ascend’s head of global consultancy, Rob Morris, this demand is only increasing. The shortage of passenger planes has driven up demand for freighters, and this trend is expected to continue as global trade booms.
In August, global cargo yields—unit revenues per available cargo ton kilometer—rose by 12%, marking the highest annual increase in over two years, according to the International Air Transport Association (IATA). This surge underscores the critical role that air cargo plays in today’s interconnected economy.
Why the 777F? Emirates' Strategic Choice
Emirates’ decision to expand its 777F freighter fleet is rooted in the plane's proven performance and reliability. The Boeing 777F offers superior fuel efficiency, long-range capability, and payload capacity, making it an ideal choice for global cargo operations. As one of the most trusted and widely used freighters in the world, the 777F has become a cornerstone of Emirates’ growing air freight strategy.
Despite frustrations over the 777X delays, Emirates’ commitment to the 777F highlights the airline's forward-looking approach. While the passenger version of the 777X has been delayed, the freighter version of the 777X could provide Emirates with the next generation of cargo transport, further reinforcing its dominance in the sector.
Looking Ahead: Emirates' Cargo Ambitions
As Emirates prepares to triple its cargo fleet by 2030, its investment in freighters, both existing models like the 777F and future ones like the Airbus A350F and Boeing 777X freighter, signals a bold ambition to capture a larger share of the global cargo market.
With global demand for cargo showing no signs of slowing down and airlines increasingly turning to dedicated freighters to meet this need, Emirates is positioning itself at the forefront of the cargo revolution. In the coming years, it will be fascinating to see how these strategic moves translate into market leadership for Emirates in the world of air freight.
Conclusion: Emirates’ Cargo Strategy Set to Reshape the Industry
Emirates’ expansion of its freighter fleet—particularly with the addition of more Boeing 777F aircraft—comes at a critical time for the global aviation industry. With demand for air cargo soaring and delays in passenger plane production continuing, Emirates is taking proactive steps to secure its role as a global leader in cargo transport. This bold approach, coupled with its plans to introduce new freighter models, signals a dynamic future for both Emirates and the cargo industry as a whole.
Will Emirates’ strategic cargo investments set a new standard in air freight? Only time will tell, but the airline certainly seems to be on the right track.
With Inputs from Reuters
Read next
Is Tata’s Air India Express Poised to Challenge IndiGo's Market Dominance?
Abhishek Nayar
17 Oct 2024
In a bold and strategic move, the Tata Group is gearing up to reshape India’s aviation landscape by expanding the fleet of its budget airline, Air India Express. This expansion comes as part of the group's broader plan to consolidate and optimize its aviation business, aiming to capture a larger share of India’s competitive no-frills airline market, currently dominated by IndiGo.
Fleet Expansion: A Game-Changing Move
As part of this ambitious plan, Tata Group will transfer all-economy aircraft from its full-service carriers—Air India and Vistara—to Air India Express. The initial phase of this strategy will see 17 Airbus A320 Neo planes from Air India join the Air India Express fleet, while 10 more all-economy A320 Neo aircraft from Vistara will follow after the much-anticipated merger between Air India and Vistara is finalized. This entire transition is projected to be completed by mid-2025.
Simultaneously, Air India Express is expanding its own fleet with the addition of 15 new Boeing 737 Max planes by mid-2024. The airline has already strengthened its operations by adding 26 new Boeing 737-8 aircraft over the last 10 months. This infusion of new planes is set to substantially boost the airline's capacity and competitiveness in the no-frills sector.
Consolidation of Tata’s Aviation Business
Tata Group’s aviation restructuring strategy will ultimately consolidate its four airlines—Air India, Vistara, Air India Express, and the recently merged AirAsia India—into two main entities: Air India, which will focus on premium, full-service travel, and Air India Express, catering to the low-cost, budget segment.
Speaking about the shift, a source familiar with the development mentioned, "The group intends to be very clear in terms of positioning its brands. These aircraft are in all-economy seating and fit better in Air India Express, which will be the brand in the no-frills segment."
This move underscores Tata’s intent to clearly differentiate its full-service and budget airlines, much like other successful global airline conglomerates. The ultimate goal is to provide more streamlined service, better customer targeting, and increased operational efficiency across all segments of the aviation market.
Competing with IndiGo: A Smart Play?
Air India Express's fleet expansion is poised to increase the competition against IndiGo, India's largest and most successful low-cost carrier (LCC). According to data from the global travel data provider OAG, 71% of the airline seats in India belong to low-cost carriers, and IndiGo holds a significant share of that market.
To effectively challenge IndiGo’s dominance, Air India Express will need more than just fleet expansion. Its network, pricing strategies, and customer experience will be key factors in swaying budget-conscious travelers. Tata’s plan to unlock synergies from the merger of AirAsia India and Air India Express could provide the operational scale and network reach needed to go head-to-head with IndiGo, particularly in the domestic and short-haul international markets.
A New Chapter for Air India Express
A major milestone in this transformation occurred when Air India Express received final approval from India’s Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) to merge AirAsia India with itself, consolidating the operations of the two budget airlines into a single entity. This merger will enable Air India Express to streamline operations, optimize costs, and better position itself in the fast-growing budget airline sector.
An official involved in the process stated, “We will ride upon our huge fleet and network expansion, in the domestic India market and short-haul international region—unlocking synergies with the merger of the two entities, and network integration with Air India."
Looking Ahead: A Stronger Competitor?
As the merger progresses and Air India Express expands its fleet, it is clear that Tata is not just reacting to market conditions but proactively positioning itself for long-term success. The strategy to optimize its no-frills brand with a massive fleet and operational overhaul has the potential to reshape the budget airline industry in India.
Whether this will be enough to challenge IndiGo’s market dominance remains to be seen, but Tata’s moves are likely to ignite a new phase of intense competition in India’s aviation sector. With increased options for travelers and a reshaped airline market, passengers stand to benefit from improved service offerings and more competitive pricing.
In the coming months, all eyes will be on how Air India Express capitalizes on its fleet expansion and whether it can secure its place as a formidable player in India's budget airline market.
With Inputs from Times of India
Read next
Jet Airways Revival: JKC’s Battle in Court Over Delayed Resolution
Abhishek Nayar
17 Oct 2024
Jet Airways, once a giant in the Indian aviation industry, has been grounded since April 2019 due to severe liquidity issues. Over the years, efforts to revive the airline have faced multiple legal and financial roadblocks. The Jalan Kalrock Consortium (JKC), which emerged as the successful bidder in 2021, has been at the center of this revival plan. However, the consortium now finds itself entangled in a complex legal dispute with creditors and lenders. Here’s a closer look at the ongoing situation and the battle to bring Jet Airways back to the skies.
A Long Road to Revival: The NCLT and NCLAT Verdicts
In January 2023, the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) in Mumbai gave its verdict, approving the transfer of ownership of Jet Airways to the Jalan Kalrock Consortium. This was seen as a significant step in the airline’s revival, offering hope that the grounded carrier would return to operation. However, the situation soon turned complicated. The creditors, led by the State Bank of India (SBI), Punjab National Bank (PNB), and JC Flowers Asset Reconstruction Private Limited, challenged the decision, leading to a prolonged legal tussle.
In March 2023, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) upheld the NCLT’s ruling, directing the transfer of ownership to JKC and setting a 90-day deadline for the process to be completed. Yet, the banks filed an appeal against the decision, arguing that JKC had defaulted on payments outlined in the resolution plan.
The Compliance Question: Delayed Payments and Performance Bank Guarantee
One of the central issues in this case is JKC’s compliance with the court-approved resolution plan. According to the creditors, JKC has fallen behind on its payment schedule by nearly four years. Additional Solicitor General N Venkatramani, representing the banks, highlighted this non-compliance, stating that the consortium had defaulted on payments due under the plan, a critical part of the resolution process.
A significant point of contention is the consortium’s failure to infuse funds in cash and execute the Performance Bank Guarantee (PBG). JKC had earlier paid Rs 150 crore as PBG, which the NCLAT ordered to be adjusted towards the Rs 350 crore first tranche payment. The consortium had reportedly completed an infusion of Rs 100 crore in September 2023, fulfilling its financial commitment of Rs 350 crore equity as per the resolution plan.
Consortium’s Defense: External Factors Delaying Revival
In response to the allegations, JKC’s legal counsel, senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi, argued that the delay in reviving Jet Airways was not solely the fault of the consortium. Rohatgi pointed to external factors such as delays in obtaining necessary security clearances and other procedural hurdles as the main causes behind the delays. He also accused the creditors of obstructing the resolution process at every stage, which he claimed had resulted in losses exceeding Rs 600 crore for JKC.
Rohatgi defended the consortium’s actions, stating that reviving an airline is a complex commercial endeavour that cannot be rushed. He further argued that the creditors’ repeated pleas and objections were only exacerbating the situation, making it harder for JKC to meet its obligations under the resolution plan.
Supreme Court’s Concerns: Seeking Clarifications
The Supreme Court, which is hearing the appeal filed by the banks, has expressed its concerns over JKC’s compliance with the resolution plan. A bench comprising Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud and Justices J.B. Pardiwala and Manoj Misra has questioned the consortium’s performance and sought clarifications on why it had not complied with previous court directives.
The bench specifically inquired about the delays in the infusion of funds and the execution of the PBG. The hearing is set to resume on October 16, 2024, and the court is expected to further scrutinize JKC’s compliance with the resolution plan.
Jet Airways: Is the Revival Still on Track?
Despite the ongoing legal battle, the Jalan Kalrock Consortium remains optimistic about Jet Airways’ revival. In September 2023, the consortium completed an additional infusion of Rs 100 crore, fulfilling its total financial commitment of Rs 350 crore as required by the resolution plan. This suggests that JKC is serious about bringing Jet Airways back to life.
The airline had earlier indicated its plans to relaunch operations in 2024. However, given the current legal impasse, this timeline may face further delays if the court fails to resolve the issues between the consortium and the creditors swiftly.
The Future of Jet Airways: Uncertain but Promising
The revival of Jet Airways has become a long-drawn battle, with no clear resolution in sight. While the Jalan Kalrock Consortium has made significant strides towards fulfilling its commitments, the legal disputes with creditors have delayed the process. As both sides gear up for the next Supreme Court hearing, the fate of the once-iconic airline hangs in the balance.
For now, the revival of Jet Airways remains uncertain, but with JKC’s commitment to financial compliance and the court’s eventual resolution, there is still hope that the carrier will take to the skies once again. The aviation industry, creditors, and eager passengers are watching closely to see how this high-stakes drama unfolds.
Conclusion: Will Jet Airways Fly Again?
Jet Airways, once India’s largest private airline, is poised for a potential comeback, but the path to revival is fraught with challenges. With the legal battle between JKC and the creditors showing no signs of abating, the airline’s future remains uncertain. However, with financial commitments being met and ongoing court proceedings, there is cautious optimism that Jet Airways may soon soar again, reclaiming its place in the Indian skies.
Read next
What consequences do deteriorating India-Canada diplomatic relations have for aviation?
Editorial Team
16 Oct 2024
From November 2024 onwards, Air India has doubled down on Toronto and continued daily Vancouver operations from the Indian capital using their Boeing 777-300ER. On the other side, Air Canada marred by Russian airspace ban and internal operational challenges have not been able to fully capitalise on increased demand for travel post covid-19. The degradation of diplomatic relations between India and Canada can have significant implications on aviation, affecting both airlines and passengers. Here are some of the key impacts:
Reduced Flights and Routes
Flight suspensions: When diplomatic tensions rise, one of the immediate effects can be the reduction in flights between the two countries. Airlines may cancel or reduce the frequency of flights due to lower demand, government restrictions, or operational concerns.
Reduced flight options: With fewer flights, passengers traveling between India and Canada might face fewer options, longer layovers, and higher costs due to a lack of competition on popular routes.
Increased Airfares
Higher ticket prices: With a reduction in the number of flights, there could be a supply-demand imbalance. Fewer available seats, combined with stable or high demand for travel, could lead to increased airfares on direct and connecting flights between India and Canada.
Fuel and route adjustments: If airlines are forced to reroute flights (avoiding specific airspaces due to diplomatic reasons or air restrictions), operating costs could rise, which in turn could drive up ticket prices.
Visa and Travel Restrictions
Visa delays or restrictions: Diplomatic tensions often lead to delays or restrictions in the issuance of visas, making travel between the two countries more difficult. This can result in a reduced number of passengers flying, particularly for tourists, students, and business travellers.
Stranded passengers: In extreme cases, political disputes can lead to abrupt flight cancellations or even temporary bans on flights between the countries, potentially stranding passengers or causing disruptions to planned travel.
Impact on Airlines
Revenue losses: Airlines operating between India and Canada, such as Air India and Air Canada, could face significant revenue losses if the number of passengers declines or flights are cancelled.
Operational challenges: Airlines might also need to reassess their strategies, potentially adjusting crew schedules, aircraft usage, or redeploying resources to other routes to mitigate the financial impact of reduced India-Canada travel demand.
Effect on Tourism and Business Travel
Tourism decline: Tourism is one of the sectors that can be directly impacted by diplomatic tensions. Fewer flights and visa restrictions would deter travellers from visiting either country, harming the tourism industries.
Business travel impact: Business ties between India and Canada, particularly in sectors like technology, agriculture, and education, might suffer due to the reduced ease of travel, further impacting commercial airlines that rely on business travellers.
Implications for Students and Families
Student travel: Canada is a popular destination for Indian students pursuing higher education. Diplomatic tensions can make travel more difficult, potentially deterring new students from choosing Canada or making it harder for current students to visit family back home.
Family visits: Families in both countries, particularly those who rely on regular travel for personal reasons, could experience challenges with flights, visa processing, and higher travel costs.
Possible Retaliatory Measures
Airspace restrictions: In a worst-case scenario, either country might restrict or deny access to their airspace for the other’s national carriers, which could significantly affect flight operations, requiring costly detours or cancellations.
Further diplomatic actions: If tensions escalate, other diplomatic measures such as reciprocal bans on flights could follow, leading to complete disruptions in aviation connectivity.
What is expected
While diplomatic tensions between India and Canada might not immediately result in drastic changes in aviation, prolonged or escalating disputes could lead to disruptions in flights, increased airfares, operational challenges for airlines, and reduced travel between the two nations. These impacts would ripple through the broader economy, affecting tourism, trade, and people-to-people connections.
Comment